Framework For Managing Ambiguity in the Workplace

A guide for product managers who face uncertainty and complexity in their products

As a product manager, you are often faced with ambiguity in your work. Ambiguity means that there is a lack of clarity or certainty about a situation, a problem, or a solution. Ambiguity can arise from various sources, such as incomplete or conflicting information, changing requirements, multiple stakeholders, or competing priorities. It can also be inherent in innovation, as you are trying to create something new and valuable that has not been done before.

Regardless of where it comes from, ambiguity can be challenging and stressful, as it can lead to confusion, doubt, frustration, or paralysis. However, ambiguity is also part of the role and as a product manager, you need to be comfortable navigating the unknowns and ambiguity. In fact, ambiguity can be an opportunity to learn, experiment, and innovate. The key is to have the right mindset and skills to deal with ambiguity effectively and efficiently.

In this blog post, we will share some tips on how to deal with ambiguity in the workplace;

1. Ask questions to get different perspectives
2. Clarify the goals and expectations
3. Get feedback on your decision
4. Time-box the decision
5. Communicate the decision clearly
6. Don’t get caught up in overanalyzing

Ask questions to get different perspectives

One of the first steps to deal with ambiguity is to ask questions. Questions can help you gather more information, uncover assumptions, identify gaps, and challenge your own thinking. Questions can also help you get different perspectives from other people, such as your customers, users, stakeholders, team members, or experts. By asking questions, you can broaden your understanding of the situation, the problem, and the possible solutions.

Some examples of questions you can ask are:

• What is the problem we are trying to solve?
• What are the root causes of the problem?
• What are the desired outcomes and benefits?
• What are the assumptions we are making?
• What are the risks and uncertainties?
• What are the alternatives and trade-offs?
• What are the criteria for evaluating the solutions?
• What are the best practices or benchmarks?
• What are the feedback or data we have?
• What are the opinions or preferences of others?

While these questions may lead to more ambiguity or other requirements, it helps provide you with a more wholistic view of the problem. You may not be able to have answers for all of these questions, but it helps you narrow down what you know, what you don’t know, and what you need to find out.

Clarify the goals and expectations

Another step to deal with ambiguity is to clarify the goals and expectations of the project. Goals and expectations can help you define the scope, the direction, and the success metrics of the project. They can also help you align with your stakeholders and team members on the vision, the value proposition, and the priorities of the project. By clarifying the goals and expectations, you can reduce the ambiguity and focus on the most important aspects of the project.

A few examples of goals and expectations you can clarify are:

• What is the purpose and scope?
• What are the specific and measurable objectives?
• What are the key deliverables and milestones?
• What are the roles and responsibilities of the team?
• What are the expectations and requirements of the stakeholders?
• What are the resources and constraints?
• What are the risks?
• What are the timelines and deadlines?
• How will the product/project be monitored and evaluated?

Get feedback on your decision

Once you have gathered enough information and perspectives, you can make a decision based on the best available data and logic. However, making a decision does not mean that you have resolved the ambiguity completely. There may still be some unknowns or uncertainties that can affect the outcome of your decision. Therefore, it is important to get feedback on your decision from your customers, users, stakeholders, team members, or experts. Feedback can help you validate your assumptions, test your hypotheses, measure your results, and learn from your mistakes. Feedback can also help you improve your decision, adjust your plan, or pivot your strategy if needed.

• Customer feedback: You can get feedback from your customers or users by conducting surveys, interviews, focus groups, usability tests, or beta tests. You can ask them about their needs, or preferences.
• Stakeholder feedback: You can get feedback from your stakeholders by having regular meetings, reports, presentations, or demos. You can ask them about their expectations, requirements, or how the new product/feature would impact them.
• Team feedback: Your team members may have some experience with the product and getting their feedback through daily stand-ups, retrospectives, or peer reviews could be helpful to pursue. You can ask them about their progress, challenges, collaboration, or learning.
• Expert feedback: Consulting mentors, coaches, advisors, or consultants can help provide you with necessary context for areas you may not be well-versed in. You can ask them about their insights, advice, or recommendations.

Getting feedback from various sources, while valuable, can take a lot of time. It is important to know how much time you have to prioritize the most important feedback and from which audience will have the most impact. If time is limited; which it usually is, prioritize collecting feedback from those that are closest to the problem.

Time-box the decision

When dealing with an ambiguous scenario, the unknowns are great and may take a while to get answers to those questions. The challenge here is time may not be on your side, it is important to know when you need to start and what the expectations are for launching or releasing this new product or feature. A great way to make sure you are not getting too caught up with the unknown is to time-box your decisions. Time-boxing means that you set a specific and reasonable time limit for deciding, and you stick to it. Time-boxing can help you avoid analysis paralysis, which is the state of overthinking and overanalyzing a situation to the point of not being able to make a decision. Time-boxing can also help you balance the quality and the speed of the decision, as you can make a good enough decision within the given time frame.

How can you time-box the ambiguity?

Prioritize the most important or urgent decisions first

Knowing what the top priorities are helps you decide which decisions should be made first and where to spend most of your time.

Break down the decision into smaller and simpler steps

Ambiguous projects can sometimes seem ambiguous because they are large. Breaking down the decisions to smaller simpler steps can help you make progress instead of feeling overwhelmed by what you don’t know.

Think long term

Even though you don’t want to spend too much time on a particular question or topic, you still need to consider the long term impacts of decision. Understanding how this decision could impact the product in 10 months or 10 years is a worthy assessment to do to ensure you are not thinking about the short-term success.

Consider other options

When working on a singular product or project, we tend to get tunnel vision. This tunnel vision forces us to focus on a particular scenario or resolutions. You can create a decision matrix to compare and understand alternatives to make sure that you have considered other alternatives to and evaluate how each would work.

Communicate the decision clearly

Even with ambiguity, communication is still key. Whenever you make a decision, it is important that it is communicated clearly to your customers, users, stakeholders, team members, or experts. Communicating the decision clearly means that you explain the rationale, the process, and the outcome of the decision in a concise, transparent, and convincing way. Communicating the decision clearly can help you gain the trust, the buy-in, and the support of others. It can also help you avoid misunderstandings, conflicts, or resistance that may arise from ambiguity. Now for external customers you may not be able to be as transparent as you’d like, but transparency with customers goes a long way with building trust.

Don’t get caught up in overanalyzing

I know this was addressed in the time-boxing path, but this is important because it happens so much within organizations when decisions need to be made. One of the common pitfalls of dealing with ambiguity is to get caught up in overanalyzing the situation, the problem, or the solution. Overanalyzing means that you spend too much time and energy on collecting, processing, or evaluating the information, without making any progress or taking any action. Overanalyzing can be caused by various factors, such as fear of failure, perfectionism, procrastination, too many decision makers, or indecisiveness. Overanalyzing can also be counterproductive and detrimental, as it can lead to stress, anxiety, fatigue, poor decisions, or missed opportunities. To avoid overanalyzing, recognize the symptoms of it, do you feel stuck on a particular decision? how long have we spent looking at the data? do we understand what the priorities are? do we all align on the expectations?  

Dealing with ambiguity in the workplace is a common and inevitable challenge for product managers. Ambiguity can be a source of stress and frustration, but it can also be a source of learning and innovation. The key is to have the right mindset and skills to deal with ambiguity effectively and efficiently. Accepting that uncertainty is part of the job and embracing the learning and the growth opportunities. While this comes with experience, you should also learn to trust your intuition and your experience and have confidence in your abilities and your judgement. As the product manager, you own the product, take action and move forward, even if the decision is not perfect or final.

Did you find this article valuable? Stay up to date with more product management insights and resources by subscribing to our newsletter.